1940s brick Colonial home with black shutters and a white portico in November

Short answer: As of November 5, 2026, about $250,000 buys a 3-bedroom, 2-bath single-family home of about 1,545 square feet in Monroe County, NY, at about $169 per square foot. There are 67 homes listed between $225,000 and $275,000, and your money goes furthest in Greece, Irondequoit and Gates.

Key takeaways

  • 67 single-family homes were for sale in Monroe County between $225,000 and $275,000 as of November 5, 2026.
  • The typical home in that range has about 1,545 square feet, 3.3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, at roughly $169 per square foot.
  • Greece, NY gives the most space: about 1,710 square feet at roughly $154 per square foot.
  • 334 homes sold in this price range in the last three months, and on average they sold above their asking price.
  • Principal and interest on a $250,000 home with 20 percent down is about $1,363 a month at 7.24 percent (Freddie Mac, October 29, 2026).

Candlelit dining room in a Colonial home with early snow outside the window

How much house does $250,000 buy in Monroe County?

A $250,000 budget buys a 3-bedroom, 2-bath single-family home of about 1,545 square feet in Monroe County, NY, based on 67 active listings priced from $225,000 to $275,000 as of November 5, 2026. The average price per square foot is about $169, but that ranges from $154 to $188 depending on the town.

Towns with at least three listings, from most space per dollar to least (averages from live MLS data on norchar.com, rounded; year built is the median):

TownHomes for saleAvg. size (sq ft)Avg. bedsPrice per sq ftTypical year built
Monroe County (all)671,5453.3$169-
Greece111,7103.5$1541958
Irondequoit111,5803.4$1591949
Gates71,5903.3$1601975
Parma61,5903.2$1671974
Chili61,4903.3$1771962
City of Rochester101,4403.3$1831920
Henrietta41,4003.2$1881965
Webster, Penfield, Brighton, Pittsford, PerintonFew or no listings right now (0 to 1 each)

Where does $250,000 go furthest?

Greece, NY stretches $250,000 the furthest right now. Its 11 homes in the $225,000 to $275,000 range average about 1,710 square feet and 3.5 bedrooms at roughly $154 per square foot, the lowest of any town we compared. Irondequoit ($159) and Gates ($160) follow closely.

Greece and Irondequoit also have the most choice, with 11 listings each. Gates has the newest homes of the group, typically built around 1975. See current homes on our Greece, Irondequoit and Gates pages.

Where is $250,000 tightest?

$250,000 is tightest in Henrietta and the eastern suburbs. Henrietta, NY had only 4 listings in the range, averaging about 1,400 square feet at $188 per square foot. Webster had none, and Penfield, Brighton, Pittsford and Perinton had just one listing each as of November 5, 2026.

The city of Rochester, NY has 10 options at about 1,440 square feet, but at $183 per square foot and typically built around 1920. For the east-side towns, see our Town Spotlights on Webster, Penfield, Pittsford and Brighton.

What is the monthly payment on a $250,000 home in Rochester?

The monthly principal and interest on a $250,000 home in Rochester, NY is about $1,363 with 20 percent down. That assumes a $200,000, 30-year fixed loan at 7.24 percent, the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey average for the week of October 29, 2026.

Property taxes and insurance are extra and vary by town and village, so ask for the current tax bill on any home you consider.

How fast are $250,000 homes selling in Monroe County?

Homes around $250,000 are selling quickly. In the last three months, 334 single-family homes sold for $225,000 to $275,000 in Monroe County, or about 110 a month. With 67 on the market today, that is less than one month of supply, and the average asking price on the sold homes was about $217,000.

On average, homes in this range sold above their asking price. For the bigger picture, read our Rochester housing market update for fall 2026.

Tips for buyers at $250,000

  • Search below your ceiling. Homes here sell above asking on average, so leave room to compete.
  • Get fully pre-approved before you tour. With under a month of supply, good homes go fast.
  • Look west for space. Greece, Gates, Parma and Chili all came in at $177 per square foot or less.
  • Plan for an older house. Many homes in the city of Rochester and Irondequoit in this range were built before 1950, so budget for a thorough inspection and updates.

Related reading from NORCHAR

Frequently asked questions

How many homes are for sale around $250,000 in Monroe County, NY?

As of November 5, 2026, there were 67 active single-family homes listed between $225,000 and $275,000 in Monroe County, NY. They average about 1,545 square feet and 3.3 bedrooms at roughly $169 per square foot.

What is the monthly payment on a $250,000 house in Rochester, NY?

With 20 percent down ($50,000) on a 30-year fixed loan at 7.24 percent, the Freddie Mac average on October 29, 2026, principal and interest come to about $1,363 a month. Property taxes, homeowners insurance and any PMI are extra.

Which Monroe County town gives you the most house for $250,000?

Right now it is Greece, NY. The 11 Greece homes in the $225,000 to $275,000 range average about 1,710 square feet and 3.5 bedrooms at roughly $154 per square foot, the lowest price per square foot of the towns we compared.

Can you buy a house in Webster, Penfield, Brighton or Pittsford for $250,000?

Only rarely right now. As of November 5, 2026, Webster had no active single-family listings between $225,000 and $275,000, and Penfield, Brighton, Pittsford and Perinton had one each. Buyers set on those towns should be ready to move fast.

Are $250,000 homes in Monroe County selling over asking price?

On average, yes. In the last three months 334 single-family homes sold for $225,000 to $275,000 in Monroe County, and the average asking price on those homes was about $217,000. So on average, they sold for more than their list price.

Want to see what's available in your price range? Call the NORCHAR team at 585.244.4444. NORCHAR Real Estate in Rochester, NY can set up alerts for your budget.

Figures reflect active single-family listings on the MLS as of November 5, 2026 and change daily. Payment estimate assumes a 30-year fixed loan, 20 percent down, excluding taxes and insurance.